Thursday, October 19, 2006

At the risk of turning this into a purely political blog...

...or of further upsetting my lovely and sensible fellow bloggers (see last post) has anyone see the article by Neil Mitchell in today's Herald Sun ?

Apparently the racist attack on a Jewish man and his children in Caulfield last week by a bunch of footy players was "not all bad news" because Neil has surmised:



  • Anybody could have been the target of this - "Jew, Muslim, Aboriginal, Asian, Greek, Italian". Apparently women can also be the target of yobbos.
  • While it was "reasonable" for the victim to object to being called a "f--- Jew " while hearing the cheer "go Nazis" we should ask if it was reasonable for him to approach the bus the players were travelling in. Neil thinks that this escalated the "clash from ugly to violent". The "good news" is that the decision to approach the bus turned out to be OK because it another person intervened. This person we are told was "not a Jew" but was "sufficiently outraged to pursue the bus". A few others helped as well and that, according to Neil, was a "statement of deceny because these people identified as unacceptable the actions of a few idiots". (Obviously without their actions, readers of the Herald Sun would have been unable to make this judgement for themselves).
  • The President of the Ocean Grove Football Club has been "decent and sensible" because he was appalled at what happened and hoped that those involved would meet the victim and apologise to him, and that they would visit the Holocaust Museum.
  • Other "average Australians" have also expressed their "outrage and committement to decency"

In conclusion, Neil tells us that the victim has been exposed to a "snapshot of Australia:we have a few yobbos, a smattering of racism, a good deal of decency, a mix of cultures, dashes of prejudice, an underlying base of fairness, an edge of danger with our blokey culture, and too much fondness for too much alcohol."

Well, I feel better.

Anyone else want to stalk the Ocean Grove Football Club next year. We can turn up to their matches, laugh at their physical appearance and crack jokes about the deaths on the Melbourne-Geelong Road and the Pyramid Bank collapse. Let's make sure we do it in full view of their children as well, for good measure.

I need a gin.

3 comments:

I'm not Craig said...

If Neil read the same story in the paper as I did about the commnets made by the president of that particular football club, then we have a very different idea of what amounts to decent and sensible behaviour.

I was particularly appalled becuase it turns out that I actually used to know the president of that club, from many years ago when we were both working as lawyers in Geelong (it's quite a small town).

If you are planning to head down to Ocean Grove, don't forget to stop for lunch in Geelong, preferably at "The Sphinx". Worth the trip all by itself.

I think I need a gin too.

meva said...

The man seems to be a dangerous idiot. So the fact that a 'Jew, Muslim, Aboriginal, Asian, Greek, Italian' could have been the target makes it NOT rascist?

Food Kitty said...

oh, yes, that dangerous edge to blokiness; as a TV tragic, I was appalled last night when a whole bunch of male hospitality students (Oliver's Fifteen trainees) just didn't get why sexual harrassment was wrong. After all, she wasn't hurt was she, and he could risk losing his job. Waaaaaa.